Being a company director is much more than signing the annual accounts or appearing in a public deed. There is a false sense of security, deeply rooted in SMEs and family businesses, that “limited liability” always shields the business owner’s personal assets.
The reality is that, if you fail to fulfil your duties, you may end up answering with your home and your savings, present and future, for the company’s debts. And we are not only talking about money (civil liability); in serious cases of mismanagement or fraud, the Criminal Code (Código Penal) also comes into play.
In this guide, we are going to give you tools to shield your management, analysing the red lines that separate an economic rough patch from a personal legal problem, so that you know exactly what to sign, what to monitor and how to protect yourself before you receive a court notification.
Legal foundations: the scope of the duties of diligence and loyalty
The Spanish Companies Act (Ley de Sociedades de Capital, LSC) does not require you to be infallible or to get every business decision right, but it does demand a standard of professional conduct. If the company goes under because of a market crisis but you did your homework, you are covered.
The problem arises when you run the company carelessly or as if it were your private estate.
What acting as an orderly businessperson and loyal representative involves
Your obligations rest on two major legal pillars:
- Duty of diligence (the “orderly businessperson”): Honesty is not enough; professionalism is required. It means getting informed before deciding, devoting real time to the company and keeping the accounts under control. If you take a risky decision (such as launching a new product) but you act in good faith, without personal interest, with sufficient information and following a logical process, the law protects you (Business Judgment Rule). The judge will not assess whether the decision turned out to be profitable or the opposite, but whether it was taken with due diligence.
- Duty of loyalty (the “faithful representative”): You must always put the company’s interest before your own. You cannot use company assets for private purposes, take business opportunities that belong to the company, or compete with it on your own account. When faced with a conflict of interest (for example, if the company contracts with a company of yours), your obligation is to disclose it and abstain from voting.
The difference between joint and several liability and subsidiary liability in management
Understanding this distinction will help you know what risks you are taking on:
- Joint and several liability: This is the rule on the board of directors (Consejo de Administración). If an unlawful or harmful decision is taken, all the directors are liable for the full amount of the damage. You only escape it if you prove that you did not take part in the decision or that you expressly opposed it (voting against and demanding that this be recorded in the minutes). Abstaining, or the excuse “I didn’t go to the meeting”, does not exonerate you; on the contrary, they are usually evidence of a lack of diligence.
- Liability for debts (subsidiary/strict): This is triggered when the company is in a ground for dissolution (for example, because of serious losses) and you do not react. If you do not call a general meeting (Junta General) to dissolve the company or file for insolvency within 2 months, the law makes you liable for the debts that arise from that moment on. Here you do not pay for causing damage, but for breaching an automatic legal duty.
The distinction between the company liability action and the individual liability action
Claims can come through two different routes:
- Company action (acción social): It is brought by the company itself (or by the shareholders/creditors on its behalf) because you have damaged the company’s assets (e.g. you sold an asset below its real price). The aim is for you to pay the money back into the company’s coffers.
- Individual action (acción individual): It is brought by a third party (shareholder, supplier, customer) whom you have harmed directly through your conduct.
Get in touch
Need help?
Main risks and types of liability of the management body
If you think the worst that can happen is that the company closes down, you are mistaken.
The real problem comes when that closure drags your personal life down with it.
As a director, you have three open fronts on which claims can be brought against you: civil (your assets), criminal (your freedom) and administrative (your debts to the State).
Civil liability: when a director is liable with their personal assets
The most frequent case is liability for debts (art. 367 LSC), which works as follows:
- Your company incurs serious losses (its net equity falls below half of the share capital).
- This constitutes a “legal ground for dissolution”. You have a strict period of 2 months to call a general meeting and dissolve the company or file for insolvency.
- If you do not act and the company keeps operating, you become jointly and severally liable, with your own assets, for all the debts generated from that moment on.
Criminal liability: corporate offences, punishable insolvency and disloyal management
Here we are no longer talking only about money, but about possible prison sentences. The Criminal Code comes into play when management crosses the line into bad faith or abuse.
- Disloyal management (administración desleal): Using the company’s money or property as if it were yours (paying personal expenses, diverting customers to another company you own), causing financial harm to the company.
- Punishable insolvency (insolvencia punible): Causing or worsening the company’s insolvency in order to avoid paying creditors. A classic example is “emptying” the company by transferring its assets to a new company and leaving the debts in the old one (concealment of assets, alzamiento de bienes).
- Corporate offences (delitos societarios): Falsifying the annual accounts to deceive investors, or systematically denying minority shareholders their right to information.
Derivation of liability for tax and Social Security debts
The tax authorities (Hacienda) and Social Security (Seguridad Social) have privileged tools for collecting debts. If your company does not pay, they can open proceedings to derive liability (derivación de responsabilidad) to you.
- When does it happen?
- If you have closed the company “de facto” (shutting up shop without an orderly liquidation) and debts remain outstanding.
- If you have committed serious tax infringements or have collaborated in concealing assets.
- If you have not filed for insolvency proceedings (concurso de acreedores) in time.
- The consequence: You become a direct debtor of the State. Your salary, income tax refunds or property will be seized until the company’s debt is covered, including surcharges and penalties. And be very careful, because these debts are extremely difficult to cancel, even under the Second Chance Law (Ley de Segunda Oportunidad).
Effective strategies to shield your management and neutralise legal risks
Although there is no such thing as zero risk or an infallible shield, you can activate a “self-protection kit” that drastically reduces the chances of a claim succeeding, by constantly generating evidence that demonstrates that diligence.
Documentation and traceability of decisions in minutes and meetings
In a trial, what is not in writing does not exist.
The usual mistake of many directors is to draft generic minutes (“approved unanimously”) that reflect neither the real debate nor the prior analysis.
To protect yourself, the minutes must work as your black box:
- Detail the information: Avoid the bare “the investment is approved”. It is much safer to write “The investment is approved after analysing financial report X and legal opinion Y, weighing risks A and B”.
- Record any disagreements: If you raised doubts about the legality or viability of a transaction, demand that they be recorded verbatim in the minutes. That is your proof of diligence.
- Keep the supporting documents: Keep the emails, reports and contracts that prompted the decision. If, five years from now, you are asked why you signed that contract that went wrong, you will need those papers to show that, at that moment, the decision was reasonable.
Voting against and challenging harmful resolutions to avoid liability
If you sit on a board of directors and see the problem coming, you must actively distance yourself from it.
To exonerate yourself, you must follow two clear steps:
- An express vote against: Abstaining is no use, nor is the excuse “I didn’t go to the meeting”. You must vote NO and ask for your opposition and your reasons to be reflected in the minutes.
- Challenge: If the resolution is manifestly unlawful or very harmful, voting against may fall short. Case law looks favourably on you going one step further and challenging the resolution in court within the legal time limit (30 days for board decisions). It is the definitive evidence that you did everything possible to prevent the damage.
Implementing criminal and regulatory compliance programmes in the company
Since the reform of the Criminal Code, a company can be convicted for offences committed by its executives or employees… and you can be held liable for not having prevented it (culpa in vigilando).
Implementing a criminal compliance programme (a crime prevention system) is not exclusive to multinationals.
In an SME, having a risk map, a whistleblowing channel and clear protocols (for example, on how to deal with the public authorities to avoid bribery) can work as a ground for exemption before a judge. It shows that you put the necessary means in place to prevent offences from being committed within your organisation.
Acting diligently in situations of business crisis and insolvency
When the company enters the danger zone, what you do (or fail to do) in the first two months will make the difference between coming out unscathed and taking on personal liability.
Legal time limits and the obligation to file for insolvency proceedings
The clock starts as soon as you become aware (or should have become aware) of the current insolvency situation. You have a strict period of two months to file for voluntary insolvency proceedings in court.
- What is current insolvency? It is the moment when you can no longer regularly meet your due obligations (non-payment of salaries, taxes or key suppliers).
- The pre-insolvency alternative (preconcurso): If you see options for viability, you can notify the court that negotiations with creditors have begun. This gives you a temporary “shield” (generally 3 months) to negotiate without the immediate obligation to file for insolvency and with court enforcement proceedings stayed.
The most common mistake is to wait for that “saviour contract” to arrive while defaults pile up. If you let the two-month period pass, the presumption of culpability shoots up.
How to avoid insolvency being classified as culpable and its consequences
If the insolvency is classified as “culpable” (concurso culpable), the judge may order you to cover the insolvency shortfall with your personal assets (the part of the debt that the company cannot pay) and disqualify you from managing third-party assets for 2 to 15 years.
To ensure that the insolvency is classified as fortuitous (without fault), you must steer clear of these conducts:
- Accounting irregularities: Not keeping books, keeping a double set of accounts or making serious errors that prevent a true and fair view of the company from being obtained.
- Concealment of assets: Hiding assets or taking them out of the company to avoid their seizure by creditors.
- Simulation of liabilities: Fabricating debts or false invoices to inflate what the company owes.
- Late filing: Filing for insolvency long after becoming insolvent, aggravating the harm to creditors.
Liability for company debts after a ground for dissolution arises
This is the mechanism that causes the most problems because it is automatic. If losses bring net equity below half of the share capital, the company is in a ground for dissolution.
From that moment, you have 2 months to call a general meeting and propose a solution:
- Dissolve the company.
- File for insolvency proceedings.
- Or increase capital to restore the balance between equity and capital.
If you carry out none of these options and the company keeps operating, the law makes you jointly and severally liable for all subsequent debts.
Get in touch
